This is a great little combox skirmish between Big Bad Catholic, Mark Shea, and a pleasantly open-minded atheist called Toastisyummy that has been going on over at Catholic and Enjoying It.

It isn’t often you come across arguments on the internet that are conducted in good faith, and this is the reason I am linking to the exchange.  Toast disagreed with Mark, but was curteous in voicing his point of view, and it seems like he and Mark both got something out of the discussion.  I certainly did (thanks guys).  Also, check out Toast’s blog entry ‘Atheist, Not Enjoying It‘  – seems he feels he got more than he bargained for when he tussled with the Shea!